Can your parent with dementia keep living alone?
How to tell whether living alone is still working for a parent with dementia, the seven things to look at, and what help at home can realistically cover.
Why families ask this question
Say your father is 84, lives alone in Oakdale, and was told eight months ago that he has Alzheimer's disease. He still cooks for himself and still knows you. Last week he called you twice in one afternoon to ask the same question about a bill, and on Sunday you found two pill organizers in a kitchen drawer, one of them still full from September.
Nobody has told you what to do with that. If you feel like you ought to already know whether he is safe by himself, you are holding yourself to a standard that does not exist. There is no test for this and no stage number that answers it. Doctors rarely offer an opinion unless you ask them straight out, and when you do ask, the answer is usually careful, because so much of it depends on things only the family sees.
You also do not have to decide this week. Most families who end up arranging help get there in stages, and the first stage is usually just finding out more than you know right now.
This article is general information from a care provider in Woodbury, Minnesota. It is not legal, financial, or medical advice. Your own situation may work differently than anything described here. For a judgment about your parent's safety, talk to his doctor, and for free help thinking through options, use the Minnesota help line named below.
Why there is no simple answer
Living alone with dementia is far more common than most families assume. Researchers with the Living Alone with Cognitive Impairment project at the University of California, San Francisco write that estimates indicate one third of people with dementia live alone in Western countries.
It is common in Minnesota too. The Alzheimer's Impact Movement, the advocacy affiliate of the Alzheimer's Association, counts 101,900 people living with Alzheimer's in Minnesota, with 168,000 Minnesotans providing 231 million hours of unpaid care for them.
What none of that tells you is whether your father is one of the people for whom living alone still works. Two people with the same diagnosis and the same stage number can be in very different positions. "Is he safe by himself?" is a fair question and the right one to start from. What it comes down to is which specific abilities he has lost, and that varies a lot from one person to the next.
What to look at
Seven things are worth checking. Go through them as they actually are, and write down what you find, because you will want the notes later when you are talking to his doctor or to an agency.
The stove. What matters is whether he still turns the stove off. Look at the pan bottoms and the burner drip pans. Scorch marks that are new, or a smoke detector that has been taken down or has a dead battery, tell you more than anything he says about it. We have written separately about what to do when a parent keeps leaving the stove on.
Medications. Count what is in the bottles against the dates on the labels. Pills left over mean he has missed doses. If a bottle has run out early he has been taking extra, which is the more dangerous of the two and worth calling his doctor about before you get to anything else on this list.
Leaving the house. Ask whether he has gone out and come back later than he meant to, or come back by a route that does not make sense, or been brought home by someone. Families usually explain away a single episode like that, and one episode is enough to act on.
Getting help if something goes wrong. Nothing in a normal day prompts you to ask this one. If he fell and could not get up, how long would it be before anyone knew? Can he still work his phone when he is hurt and frightened?
Eating and drinking. Open the refrigerator. Check dates, check whether food is being bought and then not eaten, and weigh him if you can. Weight loss over a few months is a strong signal.
Money and the front door. Look at the mail pile and the checkbook. Repeat charges he cannot explain, unopened bills, and new subscriptions all point the same direction, as does a willingness to let strangers in. It is a horrible thing to go looking for in your own father's kitchen. If you do find it, his bank and his doctor both need to know, and neither of those calls has to happen today.
Nights. Ask what time he goes to bed and what time he is up, and whether he gets up and stays up. A lot of what goes wrong happens at night, and a family living across town usually does not know what those hours look like.
What help at home can cover
Paid help at home is bought in blocks of hours, and the hours are arranged around the parts of the day that carry the risk. For a father who is fine in the afternoon but unreliable with the stove at supper and awake at three in the morning, mornings-only help will not cover the hours you are worried about. Our page on how many hours of help a parent actually needs walks through how families usually land on a schedule.
Minnesota law puts some structure around the start of this, which works in your favor. A nurse comes to the house, looks at the same seven things you looked at, and writes down who does what and what happens if the plan breaks down.
Those steps are required by statute. Minn. Stat. 144A.4791 provides in subdivision 8 that for comprehensive home care services an individualized initial assessment must be conducted in person by a registered nurse within five days after services are first provided, and that ongoing monitoring and reassessment cannot exceed 90 days from the last assessment. Subdivision 9 of the same section requires the provider to finalize a current written service plan no later than 14 days after services are first provided, and requires that plan to include a contingency plan. If the plan you are handed does not say what happens at two in the morning when nobody is scheduled, that is a fair thing to push back on before you sign it.
Abloom Senior Living has one limit you should know about before you compare agencies. We do not provide live-in care, and no caregiver sleeps in a client's home. An overnight need is staffed as awake shifts. That costs more per night than a sleeping arrangement would, and it means someone is awake during the hours when wandering and falls happen. Abloom Senior Living provides dementia care at home under a comprehensive home care license from the Minnesota Department of Health. We are private pay and long-term care insurance only, so if your family is counting on a public program to fund care at home, start with the help line below.
When home stops working
A few of these mean the decision has effectively been made for you: a fall he could not get up from, leaving the house and not finding his way back, a fire or a near fire, and his telling you he is frightened to be alone.
If one of those has already happened, you know something now that you did not know last month. The next calls are the same two either way: his doctor and the help line below.
Care at home stretches further than most families expect, and for many it is enough for years. There is a point for some where the hours needed stop making sense and a small residential home becomes the better arrangement. Our page on when to consider a move lays out how families tend to recognize it. A family already receiving care at home from Abloom Senior Living can move to our five-resident home in Woodbury and stay with the same company, if we have an opening when you need one.
Free help in Minnesota
Before you talk to any agency, including ours, talk to Minnesota Aging Pathways, formerly the Senior LinkAge Line, run by the Minnesota Board on Aging. It is free, it does not sell care, and the number is 800-333-2433. They will walk through the options in your county with you.
Washington County can also arrange a MnCHOICES assessment, which is the state's own assessment of what someone needs and what public programs they might qualify for. The Alzheimer's Association Minnesota-North Dakota chapter runs a free helpline and support groups across the East Metro, and their care consultants will talk through a specific situation at length.
What to do this month
Go look at the seven things, and write down what you see while you are standing there. Call Minnesota Aging Pathways. Tell his doctor what you found, in writing if you can, because a written note is more likely to end up in his chart.
None of that commits you to anything, and none of it has to happen this week. It is an awkward conversation to have early and a much worse one to have late.
If you want someone to come look at the house
Abloom Senior Living serves Woodbury and the surrounding East Metro, and we will come to your parent's home, look at the same things you looked at, and tell you what we think. If what your family needs is something we do not do, or is funded in a way we do not take, we will say so and point you toward someone who does. You can request a visit here.
Frequently asked questions
Can someone with early stage dementia live alone safely?
Many people do, for years. What makes it work is usually a short list of specific supports: medications set up by someone else, a plan for how a fall gets noticed, and someone who sees the house regularly enough to catch a change. What makes it stop working is rarely the diagnosis itself and more often one of the seven things listed above.
How many hours of in-home care does a parent with dementia need?
It depends entirely on which hours carry the risk. Some families start with two or three visits a week covering medications and a meal. Others need the hours from late afternoon through bedtime, which is when agitation is often worst. Families with wandering or night waking usually end up looking at overnight coverage.
Does Medicare pay for someone to stay with a parent who has dementia?
Generally no. Medicare covers short term skilled care at home after a hospital stay, ordered by a doctor, and it does not pay for ongoing personal care or supervision. Most families arranging day to day help at home pay privately or use a long-term care insurance policy.
Can a caregiver sleep over at my parent's house?
That depends on the agency. Abloom Senior Living does not provide live-in care and no caregiver sleeps in a client's home. Overnight need is staffed as awake shifts, so someone is awake through the hours when wandering and falls happen.
What should I do first if I think my parent is no longer safe alone?
Write down what you have actually seen, with dates. Call Minnesota Aging Pathways at 800-333-2433, which is free and does not sell care. Then tell your parent's doctor what you found, in writing if you can.
Related reading
- A dementia routine worksheet for families
- When a parent with dementia starts leaving the house
- When the late afternoon is the hardest part of the day
Sources
- Minn. Stat. 144A.4791, Home care provider responsibilities with respect to clients, Office of the Revisor of Statutes, State of Minnesota
- Minn. Stat. 144A.4795, Home care provider responsibilities; staff, Office of the Revisor of Statutes, State of Minnesota
- Living Alone with Cognitive Impairment project, Facts and Statistics, University of California, San Francisco
- Minnesota state page, Alzheimer's Impact Movement
- Minnesota Aging Pathways, Minnesota Board on Aging